Can bees do arithmetic?

Bee scienceReviewed 2026-08-09

Short answerNot settled

One study in 2019 reported that bees trained to associate colours with adding one or subtracting one performed above chance. No other group has replicated it, and there is no formal published rebuttal aimed at it — what exists is cautious disagreement about whether the design excludes simpler strategies. HoneyHQ describes what was reported and does not state that bees can do arithmetic.

Where the belief comes from

The study was widely reported as bees doing maths, which is what the paper's own framing invited. The design is ingenious; the inferential distance between the data and the headline is the problem.

What was reported

Bees were trained in a Y-maze. A sample display of shapes appeared in one colour, which signalled add one, or another colour, which signalled subtract one. The bee then chose between two displays, one of which was the correct answer. Performance was reported above chance.

If it holds, it would mean an insect holding a quantity in working memory and operating on it according to a symbolic instruction. That would be a genuinely remarkable result and it is why the study attracted the coverage it did.

Why it is held back here

  • A single study, from one laboratory, with the sample sizes typical of the field.
  • No independent replication by another group has been published.
  • The general difficulty it inherits is real and published: disentangling symbolic number learning from relative magnitude learning is hard, and the same research programme's zero result has a named peer-reviewed critique arguing that continuous visual properties, not number, drove the choices.
  • Simpler strategies are hard to exclude by design. Preferring the display most or least similar to the sample would produce much the same choice data as adding or subtracting one.

The claims behind this answer

Commonly claimed, but not supported

Widely repeated and not supported by current evidence. Listed so the correction is here rather than only the claim.

Commonly claimed, but not supported

Bees can perform addition and subtraction.

Reported in one study in 2019 and not independently replicated by any other group. No formal published rebuttal targets it directly; the disagreement in the field is about whether the design excludes simpler strategies, and the closely related zero result does have a named published critique. Listed because the claim is in wide circulation, not because this site holds it.

Sources

  • Numerical cognition in honeybees enables addition and subtractionScience Advances (2019) · Peer-reviewed article
  • Non-numerical strategies used by bees to solve numerical cognition tasksProceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences (2021) · Peer-reviewed article
  • The Mind of a BeePrinceton University Press (2022) · Monograph
  • HoneyHQ editorial synthesisHEKNO Ltd · HoneyHQ synthesis

How sources are selected and weighted is set out in the sources and evidence policy.

HoneyHQ saves your cookie choice on this device. Optional analytics run only if you accept — set a preference now, or change it later on the cookies page.