Silver fir honey

Malty, resinous and barely sweet, with a balsamic depth and a long woody finish. One of the least sugary honeys there is.

HoneydewPronouncedResinousMaltyWoody

Tannenhonig / Miel de sapin

HoneyHQ reference sheet — honeyhq.app/honey/silver-fir-honey, record reviewed 2026-10-30. Values describe the honey type, not any one jar; sources are listed at the end.

The most prized honeydew honey in central Europe, and the one with an actual protected designation behind it. Silver fir honeydew is dark with a distinct green cast, malty and resinous rather than sweet, and it comes from aphids feeding on Abies alba in the mountain forests of the Black Forest, the Vosges and the Alps. In good years it is exceptional; in bad years there is none at all.

Flavour and aroma

Intensity
Pronounced, step 4 of 5, from delicate to intense
Sweetness
Moderate, step 2 of 5, from restrained to intense
Bitterness
Trace, step 2 of 4, from none to pronounced
Acidity
Low, step 1 of 3, from low to bright
Finish
Medium, step 2 of 3, from short to longFrom the tasting panel's persistence rating.

Each scale is a set of named steps, not a measurement: the boxes show order, and equal spacing does not mean equal differences.

Silver fir honey on the flavour mapFlavour families in this honey: resinous, malty, woody, mineral and saline, caramel. The full list follows the drawing.floralfruitycitrusherbaceousvegetalcaramelbutterymaltynuttymolassesresinouswoodysmokyspicyphenolicmineralwaxyanimalThis honey
  • Floral and fruity: floral, fruity, citrus
  • Green and herbal: herbaceous, vegetal
  • Warm and cooked: caramel (present), buttery, malty (present), nutty, molasses and treacle
  • Woody and resinous: resinous (present), woody (present), smoky
  • Spicy and sharp: spicy, phenolic and medicinal
  • Earthy and mineral: mineral and saline (present), waxy, animal and barnyard
Aroma
fir resin, malt, damp forest floor, dried fig
Flavour
balsamic resin, caramelised malt, a mineral saltiness, faint liquorice
Finish
Very long, dry and resinous.
Flavour character
  • Warm and cooked — malty, caramel
  • Woody and resinous — resinous, woody
  • Earthy and mineral — mineral and saline

Checked against a trained tasting panel

A trained panel's published description of this honey type exists, and the scales on this page are compared with it below. Panels describe populations of honey from a stated region and period; a single jar can differ.

Reference: Honeydew honey, 721 samples — Main European unifloral honeys: descriptive sheets; Sensory analysis applied to honey: state of the art.

How this page compares with the panel (5 of 5 agree)
This page’s scales beside the tasting panel’s
ScaleThis pagePanelAgrees
SweetnessModeratemediumYes
AcidityLowweakYes
BitternessTraceabsentYes
CrystallisationVery slowslowYes
FinishLongmediumYes

“Differs” is kept visible rather than hidden: the panel described honey from one region and period, and a record covering a wider production can honestly sit outside it.

Sourced odour and aroma descriptors

Only what a trained panel or an official honey specification has said, grouped by the International Honey Commission’s odour-and-aroma families. Each entry says which.

  • Warm — Caramel, toffee, malt, cooked sugar — the notes of browning

    • Warm· panel: Trained tasting panel
    • Powdered milk· specification: Official honey specification
    • Caramel· specification: Official honey specification
    • Burnt sugar· specification: Official honey specification
    • Smoke· specification: Official honey specification
  • Woody — Wood, resin, dry leaves, spice — the register of chestnut, heather and honeydew

    • Woody· panel: Trained tasting panel
    • Pine resin· specification: Official honey specification
    • Fresh conifer wood· specification: Official honey specification
    • Balsamic· specification: Official honey specification
  • Vegetal — Green, grassy, hay and cut-stem notes

    • Tea· specification: Official honey specification
    • Pale malt· specification: Official honey specification
The sources’ own words (10 quoted)
  • Powdered milk (smell, in the mouth): “smells of powdered milk and resin”
  • Pine resin (smell, in the mouth): “smells of powdered milk and resin”
  • Caramel (in the mouth): “reminiscent of powdered milk, caramel, burnt sugar, resin”
  • Burnt sugar (in the mouth): “caramel, burnt sugar, resin”
  • Fresh conifer wood (in the mouth): “fresh coniferous wood, spruce-tip syrup”
  • Smoke (in the mouth): “smoke, black tea with milk and herb sweets”
  • Tea (in the mouth): “black tea with milk”
  • Pine resin (smell): “light odour of resin, cough syrup” — HoneyHQ’s translation from French
  • Balsamic (in the mouth): “balsamic aroma, malty taste” — HoneyHQ’s translation from French
  • Pale malt (in the mouth): “balsamic aroma, malty taste” — HoneyHQ’s translation from French

Sources

  • Main European unifloral honeys: descriptive sheets — Apidologie, 2004 (10.1051/apido:2004049).
  • Sensory analysis applied to honey: state of the art — Apidologie, 2004 (10.1051/apido:2004048).
  • ‘Slovenski med’ — single document (PGI application, Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 Art. 50(2)(a)) — Official Journal of the European Union, 2013 (OJ C 157, 4.6.2013, p. 12–16 (2013/C 157/05); EC No SL-PGI-0005-0801-10.03.2010).
  • Cahier des charges « Miel d’Alsace » en vue d’une indication géographique protégée — Confédération régionale des apiculteurs d’Alsace (EU register, eAmbrosia), 2004 (Cahier des charges, August 2004, §IV.2.4).

A specification describes honey sold under one protected name from one region; a panel describes the samples it tasted. Neither promises what a particular jar will taste of. Translated quotes are HoneyHQ’s and are marked.

Colour, texture and crystallisation

Colour
  1. Water white0–8 mm
  2. Extra white8–17 mm
  3. White17–34 mm
  4. Extra light amber34–50 mm
  5. Light amber50–85 mm
  6. Amber85–114 mm — this honey
  7. Dark amber114+ mm — this honey
Pfund grades, palest to darkest. Outlined: where this honey usually falls. Swatches are illustrations; real colour depends on depth, container and light.

Very dark brown-black with a characteristic green-gold cast when held to the light — the green is the field mark that separates fir from spruce honeydew.

On setting: Rarely sets. Where melezitose is present it can set very hard indeed.

Texture
Thick but pourable; Runny
Crystallisation
Very slow, step 1 of 5, from very slow to very fast

Very slow — often still liquid after a year or more; sets with a coarse crystal.

Low in glucose and rich in oligosaccharides that interfere with crystal formation, so it stays liquid for years. The exception is a melezitose-heavy season, when the honey can set solid in the comb before it can be extracted — the cement honey that alpine beekeepers dread.

Typical composition

Moisture
14–18% (typically 16%)
Fructose
30–38% (typically 34%)
Glucose
22–30% (typically 26%)
Glucose-to-fructose ratio
0.65–0.85 (typically 0.76)
pH
4.4–5.6 (typically 5)
Electrical conductivity
1–1.8 mS/cm (typically 1.3 mS/cm)

These are typical ranges assembled across published work, not measurements of a specific honey. Conductivity is high even by honeydew standards, and is the measure regulators use to separate honeydew from blossom honey.

What these mean: the sugars and the ratio · moisture · conductivity · how each is measured

The insects behind it

Honeydew honey has three parties: the tree whose sap is the raw material, the sap-feeding insect that excretes the surplus as honeydew, and the bee that collects it. These are the insects documented for this honey, and how each link is known.

  • Cinara pectinatae — large silver fir aphid

    Aphid (Aphididae (Lachninae)) on silver fir · Germany · Honeydew analysed

    Formerly Buchneria pectinatae.

    Its honeydew is 2% melezitose, 15% erlose and 51% sucrose by share of sugars (means).

    Almost no melezitose, so fir honeydew from this aphid does not set in the comb the way melezitose-rich spruce honeydew can.

  • Cinara confinis

    Aphid (Aphididae (Lachninae)) on silver fir · Germany · Honeydew analysed

    Its honeydew is 2% melezitose, 14% erlose and 24% sucrose by share of sugars (means).

Checked 2026-09-29 against: Sugar, amino acid and inorganic ion profiling of the honeydew from different hemipteran species feeding on Abies alba and Picea abies (2020). Where honeydew comes from.

What laboratories and tasting panels measured

From the European reference description of Honeydew honey: 721 authentic samples pooled by the International Honey Commission. These describe a population of honeys, not this or any particular jar — the standard deviations and sample counts are here so that no mean is mistaken for a specification.

Honeydew honey: laboratory reference values
ParameterMeanStandard deviationLimitsSamples
Colourmm Pfund86± 16.455 to 118.3229
Electrical conductivitymS/cm1.2± 0.220.85 to 1.63648
Specific rotation[α]D2013.9± 5.75 to 25.271
pHpH5.1± 0.34.4 to 5.7254
Free aciditymeq/kg26± 5.616.8 to 37.1205
Lactonesmeq/kg2.8± 20 to 6.7143
Total aciditymeq/kg28.4± 6.117.3 to 40.4143
Waterg/100 g16.1± 1.213.8 to 18.5598
Diastase activitySchade units (DN)22.6± 5.612 to 33.6264
Invertase activityU/kg139± 53.659.6 to 244.4331
Prolinemg/kg468± 127240 to 718305
Fructoseg/100 g32.5± 1.928.7 to 36.2362
Glucoseg/100 g26.2± 2.521.3 to 31.1362
Sucroseg/100 g0.8± 0.90 to 2.6310
Fructose + glucoseg/100 g58.7± 3.851.2 to 66.2362
Fructose ÷ glucoseratio1.25± 0.121.01 to 1.48362
Glucose ÷ waterratio1.61± 0.171.27 to 1.96336

How a trained panel describes it

Colour
Dark to very dark; normal honey colour with green fluorescence
Odour
Medium — Woody, Warm
Aroma in the mouth
Medium — Woody, Warm
Taste
Sweetness medium; acidity weak; bitterness absent
Persistence
Medium
Other sensations
Sometimes astringent
Crystallisation
Slow

It is very commonly of a very thick consistency, due to a low water content.

The family names are a trained-panel vocabulary: woody means wood, resin, dry leaves, spice — the register of chestnut, heather and honeydew; warm means caramel, toffee, malt, cooked sugar — the notes of browning. How panels taste honey.

What each measurement tells you
Colour
Depth of colour on the Pfund scale — 0 is water-white, above 114 is dark amber. Tracks minerals and phenolic compounds, and darkens with heat and age.
Electrical conductivity
How well a honey solution carries current, which rises with its mineral and acid content. The main official test separating honeydew and chestnut honeys (high) from most blossom honeys (low).
Specific rotation
The direction in which the sugars turn polarised light. Fructose turns it left, so blossom honeys read negative; honeydew honeys carry oligosaccharides that turn it right and read positive.
pH
Acidity as a logarithmic scale. Honey is always acidic; honeydew and chestnut honeys sit highest because their minerals buffer the acids.
Free acidity
The acid present as free acid, mostly gluconic acid made by the bee enzyme glucose oxidase. Rises with fermentation, which is why it has a legal ceiling.
Lactones
Acid held in lactone form — the reserve that free-acidity titration does not see. Added to free acidity to give total acidity.
Total acidity
Free acidity plus lactones.
Water
Moisture content. Decides whether a honey can ferment and how fast it pours; set by the nectar, the weather and how long the bees ripened it.
Diastase activity
Activity of the starch-digesting enzyme the bees add. Falls with heating and storage, so a low value in a honey that should be high suggests heat or age — but some honeys, citrus and acacia among them, are naturally low.
Invertase activity
Activity of the bee enzyme that splits sucrose into glucose and fructose. More heat-sensitive than diastase, and a sharper indicator of freshness and gentle handling.
Proline
The main free amino acid, mostly from the bees' own secretions. A low value is one signal of sugar-syrup dilution or of an unripe honey.
Fructose
The sweeter, more soluble of the two main sugars. Honeys rich in it stay liquid.
Glucose
The less soluble of the two main sugars and the one that crystallises. Honeys rich in it set quickly and finely.
Sucrose
Ordinary sugar, mostly split by the bees during ripening. A few honeys — lavender, acacia, citrus — keep more of it naturally, which is why their legal limits are higher.
Fructose + glucose
The two main sugars together. Lower in honeydew honeys, which carry more oligosaccharides — melezitose, erlose and others — made by the insects that produced the honeydew.
Fructose ÷ glucose
The single best predictor of whether a honey crystallises. Below about 1.1 it sets quickly; above about 1.3 it tends to stay liquid for a long time.
Glucose ÷ water
How much glucose there is for each part of water. Above about 2.1 the solution is supersaturated enough to crystallise fast; below about 1.7 it crystallises slowly or not at all.

Population: Authentic unifloral honeys produced in 21 countries of the European geographical area, analysed by 20 laboratories in 11 countries of the International Honey Commission working group formed in 1998; published 2004.

Electrical conductivity and specific rotation are expressed on honey dry matter; every other value on the honey as it is.

Diastase and invertase are given for fresh honeys only; both fall with age and heating.

The limits are the source's 95% confidence limits, replaced by the observed minimum or maximum wherever the limit would have fallen outside the data.

One pooled class: honeydew honeys from silver fir and Norway spruce (central and northern Europe), Greek fir, Aleppo and Calabrian pines (Greece) and oaks, whose physico-chemical values the source found homogeneous. Only Metcalfa honeydew honey was kept separate.

The sensory description refers specifically to honey from silver fir (Abies alba) honeydew.

Checked 2026-09-29 against: Main European unifloral honeys: descriptive sheets (2004); Sensory analysis applied to honey: state of the art (2004). Descriptive sheet, pp. S78–S79.

Protected versions and what they require

2 protected names sell this honey type under a registered specification. Each sets limits a jar must meet to carry the name — they describe that protected honey, not every silver fir honey.

Slovenski med — PGI, fir honeydew type (Fir)

The whole territory of the Republic of Slovenia.

To carry the name Slovenski med, a honey must:

  • be harvested within the defined area above;
  • match the type's botanical description — this specification sets no pollen share for it;
  • meet the 5 physico-chemical limits in the table;
  • be produced and handled under its 5 rules;
  • be certified under the scheme’s controls.

No single test checks all of these: pollen analysis, laboratory chemistry and a tasting panel each answer part, and the paperwork answers where the honey came from. This is a reading of the specification, not legal advice.

What Slovenski med requires of its fir honeydew honey, against this page’s typical range
ParameterRequiredThis page’s typical range
Electrical conductivity> 0,8 mS/cm1–1.8 mS/cm — inside the limit
pH4,7-5,84.4–5.6 — partly outside — the protected honey is the narrower range
Sucrose< 5 g/100 gNot recorded
Water< 18,6 %14–18 % — inside the limit
HMF< 15 mg/kgNot recorded
How it must be handled (5)
  • Extraction by centrifuge only, and never from brood combs.
  • Extracted below 18.6% water; drying the honey is prohibited.
  • Strained through strainers that do not remove pollen.
  • Crystallised honey may be liquefied at no more than 40 °C; never by microwave.
  • No chemical bee repellents; bottled only inside Slovenia.

‘Slovenski med’ — single document (PGI application, Regulation (EU) No 1151/2012 Art. 50(2)(a)), OJ C 157, 4 June 2013, Single document §3.2–3.6. In English. The authority’s own English text.

Miel d’Alsace — PGI, fir honeydew type (Sapin)

The Bas-Rhin and Haut-Rhin départements: the Vosges and Jura uplands, the vineyard hills and the Rhine plain.

To carry the name Miel d’Alsace, a honey must:

  • be harvested within the defined area above;
  • match the type's botanical description — this specification sets no pollen share for it;
  • meet the 9 physico-chemical limits in the table;
  • be certified under the scheme’s controls.

No single test checks all of these: pollen analysis, laboratory chemistry and a tasting panel each answer part, and the paperwork answers where the honey came from. This is a reading of the specification, not legal advice.

What Miel d’Alsace requires of its fir honeydew honey, against this page’s typical range
ParameterRequiredThis page’s typical range
Glucose + fructose≥ 45 g/100 gNot recorded
Electrical conductivity≥ 9,5 (×10⁻⁴ S/cm, i.e. ≥ 0.95 mS/cm)Printed in 10⁻⁴ S/cm; converted here to mS/cm.1–1.8 mS/cm — inside the limit
pH4,6 à 5,54.4–5.6 — partly outside — the protected honey is the narrower range
Colour (Pfund)≥ 70 mm PfundThe document heads this row “Indice de Pfund (en cm)”; the figure is kept as printed.Not recorded
Water≤ 18 %14–18 % — inside the limit
HMF≤ 10 mg/kgNot recorded
Sucrose≤ 5 g/100 gNot recorded
Free acidity≤ 50 meq/kgNot recorded
Diastase activity≥ 8 SchadeNot recorded

Cahier des charges « Miel d’Alsace » en vue d’une indication géographique protégée, August 2004, Cahier des charges §IV.2.3. In French. Paraphrased by HoneyHQ from the document; not an official translation.

Where it comes from

Floral source
No flower involved. The sugar begins as phloem sap in silver fir, Abies alba, and passes through specific aphids — chiefly Cinara pectinatae (formerly Buchneria pectinatae) and C. confinis — before bees collect it from the needles and bark.
Origins
The Black Forest and Swabian Alb in Germany, the Vosges and Jura in France, Switzerland, Austria and Slovenia.
Origin pages

Resolved from both directions — origins this honey names, and origins that name it.

Typical harvest
June to August (northern hemisphere)

Entirely dependent on the aphid population cycle rather than on any flowering. A strong honeydew year happens perhaps twice in five, and cannot be predicted far ahead.

A typical window for the honey type, HoneyHQ synthesis — not a calendar for any one place.

The bees
Colonies are moved into the forest when the flow appears, which is often at short notice. The husbandry catch is well known to alpine beekeepers: honeydew honey is poor winter store because its high mineral and oligosaccharide content burdens bees that cannot leave the hive for months, so it must be taken and replaced.
Usual processing
Spun (centrifugally extracted), Coarsely strained, Raw

Schwarzwälder Tannenhonig — Black Forest fir honey — holds a protected designation of origin, which is unusual for a honeydew honey and reflects how specific and how valued the product is.

Sourced periods for this honey

Read from a source for the place named, and kept apart from the typical windows elsewhere on HoneyHQ, which are synthesis. Flowering, nectar flow and harvest are different periods.

Baden-Württemberg (sampled stands): what the sources document, month by month
PhaseJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
FloweringNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either way
Nectar flowNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either way
Honeydew flowNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayDocumented as happeningDocumented as happeningDocumented as happeningNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either way
HarvestNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either wayNot documented either way

● documented as happening, from a period given in months. – not documented either way: no source read here says, which is not the same as nothing happening. Periods given only in season words or as an onset are listed above but leave their months dashed.

JanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDecBaden-Württemberg (sampled stands), GermanyLarge silver fir aphid on silver firDFFloweringNNectar flowDHoneydew flowHHarvestMonths as the source states themMonths derived from season words
1 periods in 1 place, each read from a source for that place: Baden-Württemberg (sampled stands), Germany, Large silver fir aphid on silver fir, honeydew flow May–July (months as stated). This is a partial calendar: it shows only the places HoneyHQ has read a source for, and is not a guide to any other place. Months derived from season words use the meteorological seasons for the hemisphere. Sources: Sugar, amino acid and inorganic ion profiling of the honeydew from different hemipteran species feeding on Abies alba and Picea abies. Drawing: HoneyHQ (HEKNO Ltd), original.

Every sourced period, on the honey atlas

What to do with it

A cheese-board and breakfast honey in its home regions. Its moderate sweetness makes it usable in quantity where a very sweet honey would cloy.

At the tableSpreadingWith cheeseBakingGlazing and roastingIn hot drinks

Pairings

  • Alpine cheeses — Comté, Gruyère, VacherinClassic

    Two products of the same forest and pasture, and a pairing that has existed as long as both have.

  • Dark rye and pumpernickelClassic

    Malt against malt, with neither trying to be sweet.

  • Strong black coffee

    The honey's resinous bitterness follows the coffee rather than sweetening away from it.

Pairing pages this honey appears on

Selected by this honey’s own recorded intensity, flavour families and uses rather than by anything written above — each page prints the rule that put it there.

Similar honeys and substitutes

Three different questions with different answers: a honey that tastes alike can behave differently in a recipe, and the same set texture says nothing about flavour. Each list is chosen from the recorded fields that matter to its question — and, where tasting panels or specifications described both honeys, the terms they share — and every suggestion says which, and what will be different. Compare it side by side or build a tasting flight.

Tastes similar

If you like this honey, try

  • Spruce honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Both malty, woody, mineral, caramel and resinous
    • Same intensity — pronounced
    • Shares its bitterness
    • Sources describe both with pine resin and tea

    Different: less sweet (sweetness: restrained)

  • Forest honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Both resinous, malty, mineral and woody
    • Same intensity — pronounced
    • Shares its bitterness
    • Sources describe both with pine resin and caramel
  • Pine honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Both resinous, woody, malty and mineral
    • Same intensity — pronounced
    • Shares its bitterness

    Different: less sweet (sweetness: restrained)

Cooks similarly

If it is not available for a recipe, use

  • Pine honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Same intensity (pronounced), so it shows through a recipe to the same degree
    • Recorded for the same uses: at the table, spreading and with cheese
  • Spruce honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Same intensity (pronounced), so it shows through a recipe to the same degree
    • Recorded for the same uses: at the table, spreading and with cheese
  • Forest honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Same intensity (pronounced), so it shows through a recipe to the same degree
    • Recorded for the same uses: at the table, spreading and with cheese

Same texture

For the same feel in the jar, try

  • Forest honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Also sold thick but pourable and runny
    • Crystallises at the same very slow rate
    • Same coarse crystal when it sets
  • Mangium honey

    Similar because

    • Also sold thick but pourable and runny
    • Crystallises at the same very slow rate
    • Same coarse crystal when it sets
  • Pine honeydew honey

    Similar because

    • Also sold thick but pourable and runny
    • Crystallises at the same very slow rate
    • Same coarse crystal when it sets

History and traditional use

Honeydew honey was long regarded across northern Europe as an inferior and difficult product. The Black Forest inverted that judgement in the twentieth century and built a premium around it — a reminder that the ranking of honeys is cultural as much as chemical.

Sources

  • Council Directive 2001/110/EC relating to honey — Council of the European Union (2001) · Regulatory guidance Link
  • Standard for Honey (CXS 12-1981) — Codex Alimentarius Commission, FAO/WHO (1981) · Standards document Link
  • HoneyHQ editorial synthesis — HEKNO Ltd · HoneyHQ synthesis

How sources are selected and weighted is set out in the sources and evidence policy.

Guides that cover this honey

Tools for choosing and using honey

HoneyHQ saves your cookie choice on this device. Optional analytics run only if you accept — set a preference now, or change it later on the cookies page.